Caffè Italia is a welcoming ice cream shop and café experience in Deer Park, NY, where visitors can enjoy a relaxing stop that feels both convenient and memorable.
Located at 1745 Deer Park Ave, this neighborhood favorite has earned an impressive 4.70 out of 5 rating from 366 reviews, reflecting the strong trust and satisfaction of the people it serves.
Whether you are stopping in for a quick treat, meeting a friend for a casual break, or looking for a comfortable place to enjoy something sweet on your own, Caffè Italia offers an inviting atmosphere designed to make every visit easy and enjoyable.
What makes Caffè Italia especially appealing is the combination of quality, comfort, and flexibility. Guests can choose from delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, on-site services, takeaway, and dine-in, making it simple to enjoy their favorite treats in the way that best fits their day.
The shop is known for its great dessert selection, coffee, seating, and table service, creating a space that works well for solo dining as well as relaxed gatherings.
Its casual, cozy, quiet, and trendy setting gives customers a pleasant place to slow down and enjoy the moment, while the availability of restroom facilities adds another layer of convenience.
Accessibility and ease of use are also thoughtfully built into the experience. Caffè Italia offers a wheelchair-accessible car park, wheelchair-accessible entrance, and wheelchair-accessible toilet, helping ensure that more guests can visit comfortably. Planning a quick visit is easy, and payments are straightforward with credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments accepted.
For customers seeking a dependable spot that combines warm service, excellent dessert, and a smooth, welcoming experience, Caffè Italia stands out as a place worth returning to again and again. Call +1 631-667-0201 to learn more or plan your visit.
Popular Items
Frequently ordered and highly recommended items at Caffè Italia
Our Story
Welcome to a place where great food meets warm hospitality. We believe dining is more than just a meal - it's an experience to be savored and shared.
Our kitchen is dedicated to creating dishes that bring people together, using recipes that honor tradition while embracing innovation.
Photos
A glimpse of our restaurant experience
Food & Drinks
Basil pesto, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, roasted peppers, baby arugula with balsamic vinegar.
Turkey, fresh mozzarella, baby arugula with balsamic vinegar.
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella and broccoli rabe.
Sweet soppressata, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, baby arugula with balsamic vinegar.
Ham, swiss cheese, tomatoes and baby arugula.
Rio mare tuna and fresh tomatoes.
Pick gelato flavors. Small you can mix up to 2 flavors.
Large you can mix up to 2 flavors. Due to limited quantity, we cannot do large or extra-large sizes of our Dubai Chocolate
Brioche bun filled with gelato mix up to 2 flavors.
Pick gelato flavors. Medium you can mix up to 3 flavors
Ice cream cones.
3 scoops of our Dubai Chocolate gelato (Cannot be mixed with any other flavors)
Extra-large you can mix up to 2 flavors. Due to limited quantity, we cannot do large or extra-large sizes of our Dubai Chocolate
Pick any gelato flavor and turn into delicious milkshake. (Unfortunately, at this time we cannot do any milkshakes with our Dubai Chocolate gelato)
2 scoops of gelato topped with hot creamy espresso.
2 scoops of our Dubai Chocolate gelato (Cannot be mixed with any other flavors)
2 scoops of gelato topped with hot creamy espresso.
Pick gelato flavors. Small you can mix up to 2 flavors. Medium can mix up to 3 flavors. Large and extra large you can mix up to 2 flavors.
Brioche bun filled with gelato mix up to 2 flavors.
Pick gelato flavors. Small you can mix up to 2 flavors. Medium can mix up to 3 flavors. Large and extra large you can mix up to 2 flavors.
Pick any gelato flavor and turn in to delicious milkshake.
Pick gelato flavors. Small you can mix up to 2 flavors. Medium can mix up to 3 flavors. Large and extra large you can mix up to 2 flavors.
Pick gelato flavors. Small you can mix up to 2 flavors. Medium can mix up to 3 flavors. Large and extra large you can mix up to 2 flavors.
Ice cream cones.
Cold espresso with milk and foam on top.
Cold espresso with milk.
Cold espresso with milk and foam on top.
Cold espresso with milk.
Croissant filled with chocolate. **This is a breakfast item and only available until 12 p.m.
Puff pastry filled with ricotta cheese. **This is a breakfast item and only available until 12 p.m.
Croissant filled with cream. **This is a breakfast item and only available until 12 p.m.
Served with cannoli cream.
Hard shell filled with fresh cannoli cream with chocolate chips.
Can choose from Almond, Chocolate Almond, Marble, Sesame, S Biscotti, Hazelnut with Cherries, & Anisette
Hard shell filled with fresh cannoli cream with chocolate chips.
Served with cannoli cream.
Can choose from Almond, Chocolate Almond, Marble, Sesame, S Biscotti, Hazelnut with Cherries, & Anisette
Macchiato for an additional charge.
Espresso with hot water.
Whipped cream and powdered sugar. Extra scoop of gelato for and additional charge.
Hear from our valued guests
Fantastic ice cream and even better coffee. You can really taste that it’s real ice cream. Super friendly staff — special shout-out to the lady with short hair. Highly recommend!
Just had the best Gelato for miles around. The pistachio and coffee was not too sweet and delicious. Reminded me of my trip to Italy!
Been here a few times now, and now that i moved to NC I was back for the holidays, I decided to take my uncle tonight and wow wow wow it never disappoints. As soon as I walk in, im almost brought to tears because it feels like home. *cues Frank Sinatra* youre greeted as soon as you walk in, everybody having warm BUT LOUD;) italian conversations at the little tables. I asked the woman which gelato she preferred and she said amaretto cookie, and so I said okay ill that one:) ! And the boss/owner intercepted and said, everyone has their own taste and took it upon himself to scoop a sample of it and I like how despite how everybody is in the fast lane and next next next (outside this place) he took the moment to go above and beyond and thats the italian way. It made me smile. Amongst the decadent gelato, the ambiance, the hospitality is what puts the cherry on top. And btw my uncle said a lot of the gelatos hes had have been ice chips but this one, perfecto. Dolce far niente. Like sitting in the car, together, reunited for the holidays, enjoying gelato. Tasting the gelato, but more, tasting a memory far richer than I could've asked.
Amazing coffee and homemade gelato. They have seasonal flavors and a lot of italian goods. Family owned. Place is small, they have a couple of tables, gets busy saturday nights. I love this place !
Love this little cafe…some of the best cappuccino in the area and the gelato is really good too. We always stop in here when I’m the area and even make special trips there just because it’s great. They have a large selection of flavors for the coffees and nice selection of gelatos (for the warmer months). If you want milk alternatives they also have oat & almond milk which I think is great because even some restaurants don’t offer multiple milk options. This is a family owned shop and if you are a regular you are basically family. They know my father in laws order like the back of their hand and always welcome to u in with a warm smile. Can’t say enough about this place! Come support local business & family owned they are cool people.
The best place I have been to for Gelato since being in Italy! Each flavor I sampled was absolutely amazing. I settled for 4 different scoops and I can’t wait to go back. We first had a lobster tail dessert and espresso. Both were made to perfection! The he top flavors for gelato were caramel, Baci, Reese’s and an amazing chocolate with an orange syrup that was out of this world! Isabella served us with a passionate personality and style! We walked out with tubs of gelato and loaves of bread. Worth the trip from wherever you are!!!
This place was worth the drive. We’ve been looking for an authentic gelato spot on the island and after much experimentation, we’ve found it. A good selection of all the important flavors, a great blend of traditional favorites and some of the new stuff. Authentic, family owned spot with top notch gelato and espresso. Will definitely be back to try more flavors soon! Blows away any ice or ice cream spot in the area.
If you have not tried this place yet - I say RUN there ! The Gelato is absolutely out of this world !!! My husband tried their pistachio , I have never tasted anything remotely as good. My decaffeinated Cappuccino was also very good . 5+++ rating on the Gelato !
Outstanding coffee, chocolate croissants and custard croissants! A nice local shop with great people.
Amazing Italian café !Charming, cozy and delicious!Great coffee, delicious gelatos, great atmosphere and consistently top-notch quality Best gelatos ever and so many flavors to pick from 😍Dubai Chocolate gelato my favorite ❤️ The very friendly barista Justyna always make my latte soo good and pretty 😍 The owner Mike is always friendly and welcoming and he make you feel like family ,the rest of the stuff is supper friendly too ! Definitely recommended!!
Common questions about Caffè Italia
Caffè Italia is located at 1745 Deer Park Ave, Deer Park, NY 11729, United States, Deer Park, NY, United States.
You can reach Caffè Italia by calling +1 631-667-0201.
Caffè Italia has a rating of 4.7 out of 5 based on 366 customer reviews.
Caffè Italia features the following accessibility: Wheelchair-accessible car park, Wheelchair-accessible entrance, Wheelchair-accessible toilet.
Caffè Italia features the following service options: Delivery, In-store pick-up, In-store shopping, On-site services, Takeaway, Dine-in.
Caffè Italia features the following highlights: Great dessert.
Caffè Italia features the following popular for: Solo dining.
Caffè Italia features the following offerings: Coffee.
Caffè Italia features the following dining options: Seating, Table service.
Caffè Italia features the following amenities: Restroom.
Caffè Italia features the following atmosphere: Casual, Cozy, Quiet, Trendy.
Caffè Italia features the following planning: Quick visit.
Caffè Italia features the following payments: Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile payments.
Caffè Italia features the following children: Good for kids.
Caffè Italia features the following parking: Free street parking.
Business Features
We look forward to welcoming you. Make a reservation or stop by - walk-ins welcome!
Request a table and we'll confirm your booking shortly.
